The upcoming Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree DLC has ignited fervent discussion within the community, particularly regarding the true nature of the Realm of Shadow. A central question looms large: Is this new area simply a veiled part of the Lands Between, or a completely separate location entirely? This debate extends to the DLC's accessibility and its place within the established timeline of the game.

Recommendation: Elden Ring Throwing Weapons Build

One prominent theory, often referred to as the "central sea theory," posits that the Realm of Shadow is, in fact, located at the heart of the Lands Between. Evidence supporting this theory includes the mysterious cloud-covered area on the base game's map, which aligns with the placement of six Divine Towers surrounding a central point. The discovery of the Suppressing Pillar, explicitly described as the "very center of the Lands Between," further fueled this interpretation. Overlay maps created by players seemingly reinforce this idea, showcasing how the landscapes of the two realms appear to fit together neatly.

This theory suggests that Marika, in an attempt to conceal her past, magically veiled the Realm of Shadow, preventing access and obscuring its existence. The looming Shadowtree, described as the shadow of the Erdtree, is interpreted as a manifestation of the Erdtree as seen through this veil. This interpretation also provides a seemingly straightforward explanation for the presence of Messmer and his forces, suggesting they arrived before Marika's act of concealment.

However, a closer examination of the available information challenges this perspective. Miyazaki himself described the Shadowlands as “sundered from the lands between”, emphasizing separation. The sheer size of the Realm of Shadow makes it difficult to reconcile with the central sea area on the map. Aligning specific locations leads to significant discrepancies, with areas overlapping existing landmarks and structures in the Lands Between.

Furthermore, the theory fails to adequately address the logistics of travel and connection. If the Realm of Shadow was once an integral part of the Lands Between, where are the roads, bridges, or ports that would have facilitated access? The existing network of roads in the Lands Between conspicuously avoids the central sea area.

Ultimately, the question of the Realm of Shadow's true nature remains open to interpretation. While the central sea theory offers a compelling explanation, it is not without its flaws. As players delve deeper into the DLC, new evidence may emerge, potentially reshaping our understanding of this enigmatic realm.

For players looking to enhance their journey through the Lands Between and the Realm of Shadow, remember you can always buy Elden Ring Items to give you the edge you need.